
Greenwashing is often seen as deliberate deception by a few large brands. In practice, most cases start with ordinary marketing copy written without evidence, a sustainability target described as if it were already achieved, or a single improvement presented as a company-wide benefit. This guide explains the common patterns, examines four real cases, compares the rules in key markets as of October 2026, and sets out a review process and checklist that a compliance team can apply before any green claim is published.
What is Greenwashing?
Greenwashing is the practice of presenting a product, service, company or investment as more environmentally beneficial than it is, through claims that are inaccurate, unclear, incomplete or unsubstantiated.
The legal test differs by market, but most regulators ask the same core question: would the claim mislead the average consumer or investor about the environmental characteristics of what is being offered? India’s 2024 guidelines describe greenwashing as including the concealment of relevant information, exaggeration, vague or unsubstantiated claims and misleading imagery, as well as highlighting positive attributes while hiding harmful ones. The UK Competition and Markets Authority’s Green Claims Code uses six principles, starting with the requirement that claims must be truthful and accurate.
Greenwashing is different from an honest error in a sustainability report or an ambitious target that the company later misses. A reporting error is a disclosure-quality issue, and a missed target is a performance issue. Greenwashing arises when the claim itself creates a misleading impression at the time it is made. Keeping that distinction clear helps teams decide which control failed and who should fix it.
What Does Greenwashing Look Like?
Greenwashing usually follows one of a small number of recognisable patterns, and most can be caught before publication with a structured review.
| Pattern | What it looks like | Why it misleads |
| Vague or generic terms | “Eco-friendly”, “green”, “sustainable”, “natural” with no explanation | Consumers cannot tell what the benefit is or how large it is |
| Part presented as whole | “Recycled” on a product where only the label is recycled | A benefit for one component is read as a benefit for the whole product or company |
| Irrelevant claims | “CFC-free” where CFCs are already banned by law | Presents a legal minimum as a distinctive feature |
| Selective disclosure | Promoting one low-impact product line while most revenue comes from high-impact activities | Creates a greener overall impression than the business warrants |
| Unsupported comparisons | “50% less plastic” without saying compared with what | The reader cannot judge the baseline or verify the figure |
| Misleading imagery and labels | Leaves, globes, green colour schemes or self-created badges that resemble certifications | Visual cues imply third-party approval or benefits that do not exist |
| Offset-based neutrality claims | “Carbon neutral delivery” achieved mainly through purchased offsets | Implies the product itself has no climate impact |
| Overstated future commitments | “Net zero by 2040” with no interim targets, plan or budget | A future aspiration is read as a credible, funded plan |
Greenwashing Examples
The four cases below are real decisions or settlements by regulators and courts; each shows a different pattern and a different enforcement route.
| Case | Authority and date | Challenged claims | Outcome |
| KLM “Fly Responsibly” advertising | District Court of Amsterdam, 20 March 2024 | Advertising suggesting flying with KLM could be sustainable, including the “CO2ZERO” offset product and statements about sustainable aviation fuel | The court found 15 of 19 challenged statements misleading and unlawful; further remedies were refused because KLM had stopped using them |
| ASOS, Boohoo and George at Asda | UK Competition and Markets Authority, March 2024 | Fashion ranges and product descriptions using broad terms such as “eco” and “responsible”, and range criteria that were not clear | Formal undertakings to make claims accurate and specific, show recycled or organic fibre percentages, publish range criteria and report to the CMA; no finding of breach |
| DWS Investment Management Americas | US Securities and Exchange Commission, 25 September 2023 | Statements that the firm integrated ESG factors into investment decisions according to its policy | USD 19 million penalty for failing to implement the ESG policies it described to clients, settled without admitting or denying the findings |
| Illustrative case (fictional) | Not applicable | A fictional cleaning brand labels a bottle “100% eco” when only the cap uses recycled plastic | Would fall within several patterns: vague term, part presented as whole and unsupported claim |
The real cases show three different routes. KLM was challenged by a campaign group through a civil class action. The fashion retailers were investigated by a consumer authority that accepted undertakings rather than imposing a fine. DWS was penalised by a securities regulator, which focused on whether internal controls matched what clients were told. The fictional example is included only to show how several patterns can combine in a single label.
Why is Greenwashing Risky?
Greenwashing exposes an organisation to regulatory action, civil claims, investor and customer loss of trust, and contractual disputes, although not every case leads to a fine.
Consumer deception and regulatory action. Consumer authorities can require claims to be withdrawn, accept undertakings, or impose penalties. Since 6 April 2025, the UK Competition and Markets Authority can impose fines of up to 10 per cent of worldwide turnover directly under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024.
Investor misdirection. For financial firms and listed companies, misleading sustainability statements can breach securities and conduct rules, as the DWS case shows. Investors who relied on sustainability labels may also bring claims.
Reputational harm. Campaign groups, competitors and the media actively look for misleading claims. A public challenge can undo years of genuine sustainability work.
Contractual risk. Retailers, lenders and corporate customers increasingly include sustainability warranties in contracts. A misleading claim passed down a supply chain can create liability between business partners.
Loss of trust in genuine claims. When claims are routinely exaggerated, accurate claims also lose credibility, which reduces the value of real environmental investment.
Which Greenwashing Rules Apply in Key Markets?
Greenwashing rules come from consumer protection law, advertising regulation and, for financial products, conduct and disclosure rules, and their status differs between enacted law, guidance and pending proposals.
| Market | Main instrument (as of October 2026) | Status | Main focus |
| European Union | Directive (EU) 2024/825 on empowering consumers for the green transition, amending the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive | Enacted; applies from 27 September 2026 through national laws | Bans generic claims, whole-product claims based on one aspect, and offset-based product neutrality claims |
| European Union | Green Claims Directive proposal | Not adopted; negotiations suspended in June 2025 | Would add detailed substantiation and verification rules |
| United Kingdom | Consumer protection law under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, with the CMA Green Claims Code | Law in force; Code is guidance on applying it | Accurate, clear, complete and substantiated claims |
| India | CCPA Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Greenwashing or Misleading Environmental Claims, 2024 | Issued 15 October 2024 under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 | Qualifiers for generic terms, substantiation, accessible disclosures |
| United Arab Emirates | Federal Law No. 15 of 2020 on Consumer Protection and advertising content rules | General law in force; no specific green claims rules | False or misleading descriptions and advertising |
| United States | FTC Act section 5, with the FTC Green Guides | Law in force; Green Guides are guidance | Deceptive environmental marketing |
European Union
In the EU, the binding rules on green claims now come mainly from Directive (EU) 2024/825, which amends the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and has applied since 27 September 2026 through each member state’s law.
The directive adds specific practices to the list that are always considered unfair. These include generic environmental claims such as “green” or “eco” where the trader cannot show recognised excellent environmental performance, environmental claims about an entire product or business when they relate only to one aspect, claims that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive greenhouse gas impact based on offsetting, sustainability labels not based on a certification scheme or set by public authorities, and presenting legal requirements as distinctive features. Future environmental performance claims must be backed by a clear, verifiable implementation plan with an independent expert monitoring progress.
The separate Green Claims Directive, proposed in 2023 to set detailed rules on substantiating and verifying explicit claims, has not been adopted. In June 2025, the European Commission announced its intention to withdraw the proposal, and Council negotiations were suspended. Businesses should check its status before relying on any summary of it.
United Kingdom
In the UK, misleading green claims are a breach of consumer protection law, and the CMA Green Claims Code explains how the law applies to environmental claims.
The Code sets six principles: claims must be truthful and accurate; clear and unambiguous; must not omit or hide important information; must make only fair and meaningful comparisons; must consider the full life cycle of the product or service; and must be substantiated. Since 6 April 2025, the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 has allowed the CMA to decide breaches and impose fines itself, rather than going to court. Separately, the Financial Conduct Authority’s anti-greenwashing rule, in force since 31 May 2024, requires authorised firms to ensure that sustainability references in their communications are fair, clear and not misleading.
India
In India, the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) issued the Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Greenwashing or Misleading Environmental Claims on 15 October 2024 under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
The Guidelines apply to manufacturers, service providers, traders, advertising agencies and endorsers. Generic terms such as “green”, “eco-friendly”, “natural”, “sustainable” and “carbon neutral” must carry adequate and accessible qualifiers and disclosures. Specific claims such as “recyclable”, “net zero”, “plastic-free” and “renewable” must be supported by credible certification or reliable scientific or verifiable evidence. Detailed information can be provided through a QR code or web link; comparative claims must be based on verifiable data, and aspirational claims are allowed only where clear and actionable plans exist. The Guidelines exclude obvious puffery and mission statements not linked to a specific product. Misleading advertisements can attract penalties under section 21 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
UAE, United States and other markets
The UAE has no rules specific to green claims, so misleading environmental claims are assessed under general consumer protection and advertising law.
Article 17 of Federal Law No. 15 of 2020 on Consumer Protection prohibits describing goods or services with false information or advertising them in a misleading way, and the UAE’s media content and advertising rules also prohibit false or exaggerated claims. Financial services firms in the free zones should also check their regulator’s sustainable finance rules. In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission enforces section 5 of the FTC Act against deceptive environmental marketing and publishes the Green Guides as guidance; the FTC began reviewing the Guides in December 2022. Other markets, including Australia and Canada, have active consumer and securities enforcement on green claims. No single global definition or penalty applies, so each market’s rules must be checked separately.
Track the ESG Metrics Behind Your Public Claimse
The First Compliance ESG reporting platform lets teams input data, track metrics and progress against sustainability goals, and produce reports aligned with GRI, SASB and TCFD.
How Can a Company Avoid Greenwashing?
A company avoids greenwashing by treating every environmental claim as a statement that must be defined, evidenced, reviewed and approved before publication, with records kept for later challenge.
- Define the claim and its boundary. Write down exactly what the claim says, whether it applies to the whole product, one component, the packaging, one site or the whole company, and what time period it covers.
- Gather evidence. Collect the data, test reports, certificates or supplier declarations that prove the claim, and record their source and date.
- Validate the methodology. Confirm how figures were calculated, whether a recognised standard was used, and whether an independent party has verified them.
- Check comparators. For any comparative claim, state the baseline (a previous product, a competitor or an industry average) and confirm that the comparison is like-for-like.
- Review the life cycle and scope. Check whether a benefit at one stage creates a harm at another, for example, lighter packaging that cannot be recycled.
- Test the wording and imagery. Remove generic terms, add qualifiers, and check that images, colours and badges do not imply more than the evidence supports.
- Secure legal and compliance review. Check the claim against the rules of every market where it will appear, including the EU’s banned practices where relevant.
- Approve and record. Record who approved the claim, when, on what evidence, and when it must be reviewed again.
Worked Example: Building An Evidence File For One Claim
The file below is fictional and illustrative. A household products company, here called Brightwell Home, wants to print a claim on a detergent bottle.
| Field | Illustrative entry |
| Original draft claim | “Eco bottle: kinder to the planet” |
| Problems identified | Generic terms (“eco”, “kinder to the planet”); no boundary; no evidence; would be a banned generic claim in the EU |
| Facts available | Bottle body contains 50 per cent recycled plastic by weight; cap and label contain none; bottle is recyclable where kerbside plastic collection exists |
| Revised claim | “Bottle body made with 50% recycled plastic (excludes cap and label). Recyclable where facilities exist.” |
| Evidence | Supplier certificate of recycled content under a recognised chain-of-custody scheme; batch test reports; recyclability assessment |
| Markets checked | EU (Directive 2024/825), UK (Green Claims Code), India (CCPA Guidelines) |
| Imagery | Leaf graphic removed; plain recycled-content statement retained |
| Approval | Sustainability lead, legal counsel and marketing director, with date |
| Review trigger | Supplier change, certificate expiry or annual review, whichever comes first |
The revised claim says less, but every word can be defended, and the evidence file shows a regulator exactly why the company believed it was accurate.
Keep Every Claim’s Evidence Where You Can Find It
Document Management stores certificates, test reports and approvals in one secure location, with search by keyword, file type or metadata.
How Should Companies Govern ESG Claims?
Companies govern ESG claims by giving each claim an owner, keeping its evidence in one place, routing it through a defined approval path, and reviewing it on a schedule.
| Governance element | What good practice looks like |
| Ownership | Each claim has a named owner, usually in the sustainability or product team, who maintains its evidence |
| Evidence repository | One central register of approved claims linked to evidence, approval records and expiry dates |
| Cross-functional review | Marketing drafts, sustainability checks facts, legal and compliance check rules, and each signs off |
| Approval thresholds | Higher-risk claims such as “net zero”, “carbon neutral” or comparisons go to senior approval; low-risk factual claims follow a lighter path |
| Vendor and supplier claims | Claims received from suppliers are verified before being repeated, and contracts require suppliers to notify changes |
| Periodic refresh | Claims are reviewed when evidence expires, products change or rules change, and at least annually |
| Board oversight | The board or a committee receives a summary of high-risk claims and any challenges or complaints |
Claims made in marketing should also match what the company says in its sustainability reports and regulatory disclosures. Our guide to UAE ESG reporting obligations and our article on ESG reporting for DFM-listed companies cover the disclosure side.
Never Let A Certificate Behind A Claim Expire Unnoticed
Alerts and Notifications sends automatic reminders for upcoming document expirations and licence renewals, with workflow alerts for pending approvals.
What are Greenhushing And Related Terms?
Greenhushing is the practice of deliberately saying less about environmental performance or targets than the facts would support, usually to avoid scrutiny or legal risk.
Not every restrained claim is greenhushing. Removing an unsupported claim is good compliance, and choosing not to market a minor improvement is a reasonable business decision. Greenhushing becomes a concern when it hides information investors or regulators need, such as climate targets or progress, or when it is used to avoid accountability for commitments already made. Related terms include “greenwashing”, where a company sets targets without a credible plan to meet them, and “greenlighting”, where marketing highlights a small green activity to distract from a larger environmental footprint.
Green-Claims Pre-Publication Checklist
Before any environmental claim is published, a reviewer should be able to answer yes to each of the following questions.
- Is the claim specific about what the benefit is, and free of unqualified generic terms?
- Does the claim state whether it covers the whole product, a component, the packaging, a site or the whole company?
- Is there current, documented evidence for every element of the claim, with the source and date recorded?
- For a comparison, is the baseline stated and the comparison like-for-like?
- Has the full life cycle been considered so that the claim does not hide a significant harm elsewhere?
- If the claim relies on offsets, is that stated clearly, and is the claim lawful in every market where it will appear?
- For a future target, is there a published plan with interim milestones and, where required, independent monitoring?
- Do images, colours, icons and labels avoid implying more than the evidence supports, and are any certifications genuine and current?
- Has the claim been checked against the rules of every target market?
- Is the approval recorded, with a date for the next review?
Key Takeaways
- Write the claim’s boundary down before writing the claim, because most greenwashing comes from a benefit for one part being read as a benefit for the whole.
- Assume generic words such as “eco” and “sustainable” need replacing with a specific, measurable statement in every market.
- Check the status of each instrument: the EU’s 2024 directive now applies, while the separate Green Claims Directive has not been adopted.
- Keep an evidence file per claim with an expiry date, so that claims are withdrawn or updated when their evidence changes.
- Align marketing claims with sustainability reports and regulatory disclosures, since regulators compare them.
Frequently asked questions about greenwashing
What is greenwashing in simple terms?
Greenwashing is when a company makes its products, services, or business look better for the environment than they really are. It can involve vague words, exaggerated claims, misleading images or leaving out important information.
What are common examples of greenwashing?
Common examples include calling a product “eco-friendly” without explanation, claiming a whole product is recycled when only part of it is, promoting a legally required feature as a special benefit, and claiming carbon neutrality based mainly on offsets. Real cases include the Amsterdam court’s 2024 ruling against KLM’s advertising and the CMA’s 2024 undertakings from ASOS, Boohoo and George at Asda.
How can a business avoid greenwashing?
A business can avoid greenwashing by defining each claim’s scope, holding current evidence for every element, avoiding generic terms, stating the baseline for comparisons, considering the full life cycle, reviewing imagery and getting legal and compliance approval before publication. Keeping an evidence file with a review date for each claim helps keep claims accurate over time.
What is the difference between greenwashing and greenhushing?
Greenwashing overstates environmental benefits, while greenhushing deliberately understates or withholds environmental information or targets. Removing an unsupported claim is not greenhushing; withholding information that stakeholders need can be.
Are green claims regulated in the EU?
Yes. Directive (EU) 2024/825 amended EU consumer law and has applied since 27 September 2026, banning generic environmental claims without recognised excellent performance, whole-product claims based on one aspect, and product neutrality claims based on offsets. The separate Green Claims Directive proposal has not been adopted.
What are India’s greenwashing guidelines?
India’s Central Consumer Protection Authority issued the Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Greenwashing or Misleading Environmental Claims on 15 October 2024. They require qualifiers for generic terms, credible evidence or certification for specific claims, accessible disclosures such as QR codes, verifiable comparisons and actionable plans behind future claims.
Back Your Sustainability Claims with Organised Data
Book a demo to see how ESG reporting, document management and alerts work together for your sustainability and compliance teams.
